Study shows alcohol impacts men and women differently.
When we think of problem or binge drinking, the face is likely male. Males are generally categorized as more likely to engage in high risk behavior like binge drinking and the social pressure for men to drink is high. Think about the stereotypical men’s social activities: watching a game, playing golf or having “beers with the boys.” Alcohol seems to be just a part of men’s social lives. But is alcohol becoming the next big women’s health issue? Alcohol marketing targeting women has ramped up in the past decade, especially in the hard seltzer category.
The hard seltzer market was $1.8B in 2020 and is poised to grow 35% in 2021. These products target an audience that is young, health-conscious, looking for low-calorie or low-carb options that aren’t beer. It’s also largely female. Early category entrants targeted women, sometimes exclusively, with thin, tall cans and colorful designs (even using mermaids or florals). This attractive packaging became popular among young women, especially when combined with the “Instagram-ability” of the product.
These trends — the increase in marketing and growth in the market — are fueling fears that problem drinking is now being normalized for women. Alcohol-related deaths for white women more than doubled during the period from 1999-2015.
As a behavioral health provider, we regularly conduct research on mental health and substance use, including alcohol use disorder and alcohol addiction, to better understand the current landscape and trends in these areas. We recently conducted a survey to learn more about how alcohol impacted different aspects of the participants’ lives. We found that in addition to reporting widespread physical and mental health symptoms, men and women experienced the effects of alcoholism, including attitudes toward getting help and relapse rates, differently.
Note: the collection tool does not identify non-binary gender in respondents. Results will be discussed based on the gender selected by the participants. This is a limitation, as there is evidence that this is a disproportionate issue in gender minority groups.
The Recovery Village Survey Results
We surveyed more than 2,000 Americans who had attempted to stop drinking (successfully or not) or wanted to stop to learn more about their experience with alcohol and how it impacted different aspects of their lives. Note: Some questions asked respondents to select each option that applied, so in a few instances, the total percentage will be greater than one hundred.
Participants were first asked how frequently they drank in a typical 30 day period and how many drinks they consumed on a typical day. Men reported drinking more and more often. They were:
- 44% more likely to report drinking every day
- 39% more likely to report drinking 5-6 times per week
- 27% more likely to drink 5-6 drinks in a typical day
Men were also much more likely to binge drink. Binge drinking is defined by consuming five or more drinks (for men) or four or more drinks (for women) in a 2-hour period. Men were:
- 64% more likely to say every day
- 81% more likely to say 5-6 days per week
- 33% more likely to say 3-4 days per week
Meanwhile, women were 31% more likely to report binge drinking just once a week, 72% more likely to binge just two to three times per month and 129% more likely to report binge drinking less than once per month.
We also asked respondents about the reasons why they drank. A majority of both groups (58%) said coping with stress, which included things like relaxing, unwinding, dealing with difficult issues. We noticed some interesting differences in the factors reported between men and women.
- Men were 74% more likely to report being physically dependent on alcohol.
- Men were also 21% more likely to say coping with mental health symptoms (like anxiety or depression).
- Women were 17% more likely to say they drank for recreational or social reasons.
These results could point to a need to give men more resources and space to take care of their mental and physical health. For women, it might be an opportunity to revisit the “wine mommy” narrative that’s become popularized in our culture and encourage women to also consider other ways to socialize and have fun with each other.
Alcohol’s Impact on Participants’ Lives
Next we wanted to know more about the impact of their alcohol use on different aspects of the participants’ lives. Once again, we noticed big differences in the effects experienced by men compared to women.
- Men were 47% more likely to say their drinking had an impact on their legal status.
- Men were 40% more likely to say their drinking affected their career.
- Men were 22% more likely to say their drinking affected their abilities as a parent.
Men were also much more likely to report adverse health complications. They were:
- 72% more likely to report liver disease
- 64% more likely to report cancer
- 62% more likely to report cirrhosis
- 45% more likely to report high blood pressure
- 43% more likely to report cardiovascular disease
- 20% more likely to report depression
In fact, women were 65% more likely to report that they didn’t experience any of these conditions.
These stats are especially concerning when studies by the CDC and NIH also show that historically, men are less likely to go to the doctor than women and when they do go, they receive less of the doctor’s time and are provided with fewer and briefer explanations. All of these results combine to suggest that men’s health is an important area with much room for improvement to meet the needs of this population.
Differences in Approach to Detox, Rehab & Recovery
For those who had attempted to stop drinking, successfully or not, we wanted to better understand barriers to treatment, the treatment experience and what happens after treatment. We found that men were much more likely than women to seek outside help to quit drinking.
- Men were 124% more likely to consider professional addiction treatment (alcohol rehab).
- Women were 112% more likely to say they did not or would not consider using outside help to quit drinking.
Our own admissions records align with these findings. Of our admissions for alcohol through mid-April 2021, 68.5% were men and 31.5% were women. This discrepancy could point toward women fearing or experiencing increased social stigma or discomfort discussing sensitive traumatic events in a co-ed setting.
Women were also much more likely (72%) to say they never relapsed since receiving treatment or stopping alcohol use. A relapse is defined by a return to old alcohol abuse behaviors. Men were 253% more likely to experience a relapse within the first two years compared to women.
- 37% of men relapsed within the first year
- 25% of men relapsed between one and two years
- 39% of women said they have never relapsed
Alcohol is a substance that has potentially lethal withdrawal symptoms. Working with a professional can not only make the alcohol detox process more comfortable, it can ensure your safety. With more men reporting heavy alcohol use, it’s encouraging that they are most open to professional help since heavy use also increases the likelihood that they’ll experience withdrawal symptoms during detox. However, it’s concerning that more women aren’t open to considering outside help.
Even if your detox isn’t necessarily life-threatening, you don’t have to experience it alone. The benefits of peer support groups are well-documented. And a professional, whether that’s your own personal therapist or an alcohol addiction specialist, can also help you identify and develop healthy coping strategies for life.
If You’re Ready to Quit Drinking, You’re Not Alone
Our survey shows the clear, negative impact alcohol can have on your health and personal life. You have every reason to choose a happier, healthier life without using alcohol to cope. If you want to stop drinking alcohol, help is always available whether that means peer support, professional counseling or specialized addiction treatment.
Professional help is available for you or a loved one at The Recovery Village. Contact us today to speak to one of our intake coordinators who will help you understand the programs we offer, how insurance can help cover the costs of rehab and how we’ll support you every step of the way.
For press inquiries, email [email protected]
Grace, Annie. “Last call! Why men can’t turn down just one more drink.” New York Daily News, September 20,2016. Accessed April 13, 2021.
English, Taunya. “Why alcohol marketing targeting women ha[…]esearchers concerned.” WHYY.org, April 24, 2014. Accessed April 13, 2021.
youT4 Labs Inc. “US Hard Seltzer Market Share, Market Siz[…]ivers, 2016 – 2021.” January 23, 2021. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Olszyk, Jessica. “White Claw has Proven the Success of Gender-Neutral Branding.” Branding Times, September 10, 2019. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Kindy, Kimberly and Keating, Dan. “For women, heavy drinking has been norma[…] That’s dangerous..” The Washington Post, December 23, 2016. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Flentje, Annesa; Barger, Brandon; Capriotti, Matthew; Lubensky, Micah; Tierney, Matthew; Obedin-Maliver, Juno and Lunn, Mitchell. “Screening gender minority people for harmful alcohol use.” PLOS ONE, April 7, 2020. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Women more likely than men to visit the […]to have annual exams.” National Center for Health Statistics, July 26, 2001. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Banks, Ian. “No Man’s Land: men, illness, and the NHS.” British Medical Journal, November 3, 2001. Accessed April 13, 2021.
Tracy, Kathlene and Wallace, Samantha. “Benefits of peer support groups in the t[…]eatment of addiction.” Substance Abuse and Rehabilitation, September 29, 2016. Accessed April 13, 2021.
The Recovery Village aims to improve the quality of life for people struggling with substance use or mental health disorder with fact-based content about the nature of behavioral health conditions, treatment options and their related outcomes. We publish material that is researched, cited, edited and reviewed by licensed medical professionals. The information we provide is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. It should not be used in place of the advice of your physician or other qualified healthcare providers.